10-Year Follow-up After Interferon- Therapy for Chronic Hepatitis C
Daryl T.-Y. Lau1, David E. Kleiner2, Marc G. Ghany1, Yoon Park3, Peter Schmid4, and Jay H.Hoofnagle1
From the 1 Liver Diseases Section, Digestive Diseases Branch, National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, Bethesda, MD; 2 Laboratory of Pathology, National Cancer Institute, Bethesda MD; 3 Warren G. Magnuson Clinical Center, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD; and 4 National Genetics Institute, Los Angeles, CA
Sustained responses to interferon- occur in 10% to 25% of patients with chronic hepatitis C, but the long-term outcome is not well defined. We evaluated the long-term clinical, histological, and virological outcomes of 10 patients with chronic hepatitis C who were treated between 1984 and 1987 with interferon--2b for 52 ± 6 weeks (total doses of 492 ± 116 MU). Before therapy, all 10 had hepatitis C virus (HCV) RNA, elevations of serum aminotransferases, and chronic hepatitis with fibrosis on liver biopsy. Clinical follow up was 6 to 13 years, and liver biopsies were done 5 to 11 years after initiation of therapy. HCV RNA was assayed by qualitative and quantitative reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction assays. Among 5 patients who had a 6-month sustained response after therapy, all remained HCV RNA negative, and at last follow-up, 4 had normal and 1 minimally elevated serum aminotransferase levels. Liver biopsy specimens were nonreactive for HCV RNA, and all the patients showed improvements in both inflammation and fibrosis and were either normal or had mild, nonspecific inflammatory changes. Among 5 patients without a sustained response, all continued to have HCV RNA in serum and persistent or intermittent aminotransferase elevations. Liver biopsy specimens showed little or no change in necrosis and inflammation; all except 1 patient had progression of fibrosis scores or cirrhosis. All 5 patients had symptoms of chronic hepatitis, 1 underwent liver transplantation, and another had progressive hepatic decompensation. In conclusion, patients with a 6-month posttreatment virological response have a favorable long-term clinical and histological outcome.(HEPATOLOGY 1998;28:1121-1127.)
Non-A, non-B hepatitis was recognized as the major cause of transfusion-associated hepatitis more than 20 years ago, when the discoverers of the hepatitis A virus showed that cases of viral hepatitis not related to hepatitis B were also not attributable to hepatitis A.1 After more than a decade of intensive research, Houghton and co-workers isolated a fragment of the genome of the hepatitis C virus (HCV) and subsequently cloned and characterized this agent.2 The development of the diagnostic tests for antibody to HCV (anti-HCV)3 and for HCV RNA4 soon followed. Application of these assays has shown that infection with HCV affects approximately 4 million Americans5 and that hepatitis C is probably the most common cause of chronic liver disease, cirrhosis, and liver cancer in the Western world. 6,7
Therapy for hepatitis C also has advanced in the past 20 years. Even before the discovery of HCV, a pilot study conducted at the Clinical Center of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) demonstrated that therapy with interferon- induced clinical and histological remissions in a proportion of patients with chronic non-A, non-B hepatitis.8 Subsequently, a series of randomized clinical trials confirmed the efficacy of interferon as therapy for chronic hepatitis C,9-12 and testing of stored samples showed that successful therapy was usually associated with loss of HCV RNA from serum and liver. 13,14 A recent NIH Consensus Conference has recommended approaches to diagnosis, prevention, and treatment of hepatitis C.15 A central issue remains whether responses to therapy are sustained and result in permanent remissions or cure of the infection and disease.
The aim of the current study was to assess the long-term survival and clinical outcomes of the original cohort of patients with non-A, non-B hepatitis infection who were treated with interferon-at the NIH in the early 1980s.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Patients. In a pilot dose-finding study conducted at the NIH Clinical Center between 1984 and 1986, 10 patients with chronic non-A, non-B hepatitis were treated with interferon- (-2b; Schering-Plough Corp., Kenilworth, NJ).8 All patients were later confirmed to have chronic HCV infection on the basis of finding anti-HCV and HCV RNA in serum on stored, pretreatment samples. The 10 patients comprised 9 men and 1 woman, were all non-Hispanic whites, and ranged in age from 26 to 62 years (mean, 40 years). The source of HCV was suspected to be blood transfusion in 6 and injection drug use in 3, and was unknown in 1. When initially evaluated, all patients had mild symptoms of liver disease, persistently elevated serum aminotransferase levels, and liver biopsy specimen changes consistent with chronic hepatitis C. Patients received interferon- subcutaneously in varying dose regimens for 2 to 19 months. In a subsequent reanalysis of this cohort, 6 patients were considered sustained responders, with no HCV RNA in serum as detected by reverse transcriptase (RT)-polymerase chain reaction (PCR) after several years of follow-up.13 One patient was later reclassified as a virological nonresponder when HCV RNA was found to be persistently positive in low titers using a more sensitive assay.16
Follow-up and Measurements. After completion of the study, patients were scheduled for at least yearly follow-up visits. Beginning in April 1996, all 9 living patients were contacted and asked to return for reevaluation. The evaluation included complete history and physical examination, a battery of blood tests including serological tests for hepatitis B virus and HCV infection, abdominal ultrasound, and repeat liver biopsy. These studies were done as a part of clinical research protocols that were approved by the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases Institutional Review Board, and all patients gave written, informed consent.
Serum HCV RNA levels were determined by a qualitative RT-PCR assay (Amplicor: Roche Diagnostics Systems, Branchburg, NJ)16 with a lower limit of detection of 400 viral copies/mL serum. The level of HCV RNA in the final follow-up specimens was measured by a quantitative PCR assay (National Genetics Institutes, Los Angeles, CA) with a lower limit of detection of 100 HCV copies/mL.17 HCV genotyping was done using the reverse hybridization assay (line probe assay, LiPA; Innogenetics, Ghent, Belgium)18 and serotyping by immunoassays based on serological differences in antibody to the NS4 region of the genome.19
As a part of the initial study, all patients underwent liver biopsy before treatment and again after 1 year of treatment. Subsequently, follow-up liver biopsies were done on all 10 patients between 5 and 11 years after starting therapy. Frozen liver tissues were available in 7 for hepatic HCV RNA determination. All liver biopsy specimens were reevaluated under code by a hepatic pathologist (D.E.K.) who was not aware of the sequence of the biopsies, patient's history, or therapy. Liver histology was graded using a modification of the histology activity index (HAI), which comprised the sum of four scores, including periportal necrosis and inflammation (0-10), lobular necrosis and inflammation (0-4), portal inflammation (0-4), and fibrosis (0-4). 20,21 Hepatic HCV RNA was measured by the qualitative PCR assay (National Genetics Institutes). Liver samples were weighed and total RNA was extracted using guanidinium isothiocyanate and phenol. The tissue RNA was then resuspended to achieve an RNA concentration of 1 µg in 3 µL of solution. A standard RT-PCR procedure was then performed using the same primer pairs as for the serum assay.17
All 10 patients initially had sustained elevations in levels of serum alanine aminotransferase (ALT; range = 148 to 460, mean = 297 ± 35 U/L) and chronic hepatitis with fibrosis on liver biopsy (table 1). Two patients had compensated cirrhosis. Testing of stored serum samples revealed that all patients were reactive for both anti-HCV and HCV RNA. Two patients had genotype 1a, three 1b, three 2a, and one 3a.18 One patient with low levels of HCV RNA could not be genotyped but had serotype 1 based on anti-HCV testing.19
The 10 patients received interferon--2b in varying regimensdaily, every other day, or three times a week in doses ranging from 1 to 5 MU. One patient did not tolerate the side effects of interferon, and therapy was stopped after 8 weeks. The remaining patients received interferon for at least 1 year. The total duration of treatment ranged from 8 to 76 weeks (mean, 52 ± 6 weeks) for a total dose of 196 to 1,408 MU (mean, 492 ± 116 MU). Five patients were classified as sustained responders based upon the lack of HCV RNA in serum and the presence of normal ALT levels 6 months after stopping therapy. The remaining 5 patients remained HCV RNA positive and had abnormal ALT levels 6 months after stopping interferon.
The 5 patients with a sustained virological response were on average younger and had a shorter duration of disease than the nonresponders (table 1). Four of the 5 responders had HCV genotypes 2 or 3, whereas the nonresponders all had genotype 1. The two groups had similar pretreatment levels of serum aminotransferases and similar HAI scores, but the two patients with cirrhosis were both nonresponders.
The 10 patients were started on treatment between July 1984 and July 1986 and completed treatment between July 1985 and August 1987. All 10 patients have been followed subsequently. One patient (a nonresponder) died of a suspected intracerebral hemorrhage 6.4 years after starting therapy while in the process of undergoing evaluation for liver transplantation; the remaining patients were seen and evaluated in 1996 and 1997. The duration of clinical follow-up from the time of initiation of therapy ranged from 6 to 13 years and averaged 10 years.
At the time of the final follow-up, the 5 sustained responders had no symptoms or physical findings of liver disease. Serum ALT levels were normal in 4 and were minimally elevated in 1 (ALT = 45; normal < 41 U/L). All 5 had no detectable HCV RNA (<100 copies/mL) in serum, but all 5 were still reactive for anti-HCV. Liver biopsies, done 10 to 11 years after starting therapy, revealed marked improvement in both the inflammatory and fibrotic components of the HAI scores (Fig. 1). Four patients had mild degrees of inflammation, but none had fibrosis above what was considered a normal or insignificant amount. Results of testing liver tissue samples for HCV RNA by PCR were negative in all 5 patients. An example of pretreatment, end-of-treatment, and 10-year follow-up liver histological findings on a sustained responder is shown in Fig. 2.
The 5 nonresponder patients continued to have symptoms of chronic hepatitis as well as abnormal levels of serum aminotransferases and HCV RNA in serum. At the time of the final follow-up clinical evaluation (6.4 to 12.6 years after initiation of therapy), serum HCV RNA was detectable at titers between 1,500 and greater than 5 million copies/mL. Liver biopsies done 5 to 11 years after starting therapy revealed no change in average total HAI scores compared with pretreatment biopsies (mean: 13.2 pretreatment, 13.2 posttreatment). Fibrosis scores increased in two of the three without preexisting cirrhosis (Fig. 3). An example of pretreatment, end-of-treatment, and 10-year follow-up liver histological findings on a nonresponder is shown in Fig. 4. One patient with cirrhosis underwent liver transplantation for hepatocellular carcinoma 5 years after a 1-year course of therapy. During the 7 years since transplantation, he has had no evidence of cancer recurrence and has had normal ALT levels despite the presence of HCV RNA in serum. A second nonresponder developed decompensated liver disease and died of an intracerebral bleed while under evaluation for liver transplantation.
The current analysis provides a 10-year follow-up of the first cohort of patients with chronic hepatitis C who received interferon- for this disease. Five patients had a 6-month posttreatment biochemical and virological response. During the ensuing 10 years, all 5 were without clinical or virological evidence of disease. These findings suggested that interferon- therapy eradicated HCV infection and that these 5 patients were cured of the chronic hepatitis C. Liver biopsies were done on all 5 patients more than 10 years after starting therapy and showed a resolution of hepatic fibrosis in all, suggesting that with eradication of the chronic viral infection, liver fibrosis can regress. Liver biopsy tissue was normal in 1 patient, but showed nonspecific inflammatory changes in 4 others. The presence of occasional inflammatory cells in liver biopsies and the presence of a slightly elevated ALT level in 1 patient may be indicative of low levels of ongoing hepatitis in these patients. However, it is important that sensitive PCR assays for HCV RNA revealed no evidence for residual virus in biopsy tissue. These results are quite different from similar studies done on patients with hepatitis B who respond to interferon treatment, who typically do not have resolution of fibrosis and who continue to have a low-grade hepatitis and hepatitis B virus DNA detectable by PCR in liver biopsies despite the loss of hepatitis B virus DNA and even hepatitis B surface antigen with treatment.22
The long-term beneficial outcome of patients with chronic hepatitis C who have a biochemical and virological response to interferon- has been documented in a number of studies from Europe and Asia.23-26 In these studies, which provided an average follow-up of 2 to 5 years, relapses in disease were uncommon among patients who remained HCV RNA negative after therapy, the reported rate of relapses ranging from 4% to 6% in the two largest series. 25,26 Possible explanations for the occurrence of late relapses despite lack of HCV RNA 6 months after stopping therapy include reinfection caused by repeated exposure to hepatitis C, intermittent viremia combined with infrequency of testing, and unreliability of the PCR assay used to detect viral RNA at 6 months. Indeed, in the current study, one patient was initially thought to be a virological responder. During follow-up, however, he developed hepatocellular carcinoma, required liver transplantation, and was subsequently found to be HCV RNA positive. Testing of stored serum samples by sensitive assays showed that this patient had been HCV RNA positive shortly after stopping therapy, but that levels were persistently low, in the range of 100 to 1.000 HCV copies/mL, and thus not detected using early generations of PCR assays. These observations suggested that the standard definition of a response to interferon- therapy (i.e., lack of HCV RNA in serum by a sensitive technique at least 6 months after stopping therapy) is a reliable standard to use in evaluating antiviral therapies of hepatitis C and may indicate cure of disease.
This pilot study was somewhat unusual for the high rate of response to interferon-. In recent controlled trials in chronic hepatitis C, the response rates to interferon- have usually ranged from 6% to 14%,27-30 significantly below the 50% rate in this cohort. The reasons for these differences are probably in the selection of patients in this study, who were generally young, without evidence of other disease. Furthermore, most of the responders in this study happened to have only mild or moderate degrees of fibrosis on liver biopsy and HCV genotypes 2 and 3, factors that are known to be associated with high rates of response to interferon. 12,18,30
The 5 nonresponders in this study were also distinctive in demonstrating evidence of progressive disease, the two with preexisting cirrhosis being referred for liver transplantation and the rest having continued symptoms with restrictions on physical activities and progression of fibrosis on liver biopsy. Studies of the natural history of hepatitis C starting with the onset of infection suggest that the progression of this disease is slow and insidious.31 However, reports on the course of hepatitis C in patients seen at referral centers indicate that this disease frequently leads to end-stage liver disease within a few years of evaluation.32 In this initial study of interferon- therapy for non-A, non-B hepatitis, patients were selected on the basis of having symptoms of disease, high levels of serum aminotransferases, and significant degrees of inflammation, necrosis, and fibrosis on liver biopsyfeatures that may predict more rapid progression of disease.
In summary, 5 of 10 patients with chronic hepatitis C who were treated with interferon- between 1984 and 1987 had a virological response and all 5 demonstrated a sustained clinical, biochemical, and virological resolution of disease. In all 5, hepatic fibrosis detected on pretreatment liver biopsies had resolved. Mild hepatic inflammation found on liver biopsy in some responders was of unclear significance but did not appear to be associated with progression of liver disease.
Acknowledgement: The authors thank the many nurses, technicians and physicians who were responsible for caring for the patients in this study, including Jeanne Waggoner, John Vergalla, Kevin Mullen, D. Brian Jones, Vinod Rustgi, Adrian Di Bisceglie, Marion Peters, E. Anthony Jones, Harvey J. Alter, and Michiko Shindo. The authors also thank Dr. Peter Simmonds for serotyping of anti-HCV and Dr. J. W. Shih for performing Amplicor assays.
Abbreviations: HCV, hepatitis C virus; anti-HCV, antibody to HCV; NIH, National Institutes of Health; RT, reverse transcriptase; PCR, polymerase chain reaction; HAI, histology activity index; ALT, alanine aminotransferase.
Received April 2, 1998; accepted June 1, 1998.
Address reprint requests to: Dr. Daryl Lau, Liver Diseases Section, NIDDK, Building 10, Room 9B16, NIH, Bethesda, MD 20892. Fax: (301) 402-0491; e-mail: email@example.com.
Some of our most commonly asked questions and our answers to them.
Tthe latest news on hepatitis treatments, clinical trials, social issues and important breakthroughs.
Learn about the Hepatitis C Virus (HCV).
You'll find links to a comprehensive symptoms list, as well as various studies and discussions about Hepatitis C symptoms.
Information about the transmission of Hepatitis C.
Learn about Hepatitis C Genotypes and their variants.
Provides detailed information on how to analyze and interpret viral load numbers as well as a link to a convenient Viral Load Chart.
Learn about the importance of testing liver enzyme levels and causes of abnormal levels.
What they are and what they mean. Helps you interpret & understand all the various hepatitis lab tests likely to be encountered.
Learn how hepatitis infection may affect the pregnant mother and baby.
Learn about the conventional medical treatments used to fight Hepatitis C.
Numerous links to studies, info sheets, FAQs, and analysis of Ribavirin/Rebetron medicines.
Alternative methods of treatment due to side effects and dissatisfication with current medical treatments.
A number of herbal products useful in the management of liver disease.
Provides information regarding the best known liver supporting supplements.
Provides information regarding the best known milk thistle supplements.
A basic diet for those with Hepatitis C.
Survivor stories that have been shared to benefit others with Hepatitis C.
Many discussions and analyses of cirrhosis, including causes, complications, pathology, symptoms, and much more.
A state-by-state and worldwide reference listing physicians who treat HCV, including an email link to submit your physician for inclusion.
A Bulletin Board for discussions on hepatitis, treatments, etc.